In standard algebra ($ab = c$), you can divide by $b$ to get $a = c/b$. In GMAT inequalities, doing this is FATAL unless the problem explicitly states that $b > 0$!
Classic GMAT Data Sufficiency Trap:Question: Is $x < 4$?
Statement (1): $x^2 < 4x$
The Incorrect Temptation: Divide both sides by $x$ to conclude $x < 4$, picking Statement 1 as Sufficient.
Why this is wrong: When you divide by $x$, you implicitly assume $x$ is positive without stating the condition $x > 0$. The resulting answer $x < 4$ mistakenly includes invalid values like $x = -2$ or $x = 0$:
- Test $x = -2$: $(-2)^2 < 4(-2) \implies 4 < -8$ (FALSE! A positive square can never be less than a negative number).
- Test $x = 0$: $0^2 < 4(0) \implies 0 < 0$ (FALSE!).
Dividing by $x$ completely erased the lower boundary ($x > 0$) and produced a distorted solution set!
The Correct GMAT First-Principles Method: Never divide by an unknown variable! Subtract $4x$ to set one side to zero and factor:
$$ x^2 - 4x < 0 \implies x(x - 4) < 0 \implies 0 < x < 4 $$
Since $0 < x < 4$, $x$ is strictly between 0 and 4, which means $x$ is always less than 4! The statement is indeed Sufficient, but understanding that the real range is $0 < x < 4$ protects you when the question asks "Is $x > 0$?". Golden GMAT Rule: Subtract and factor; never divide by an unknown variable.